Lane Splitting in Arizona (or your state)

Today I commuted downtown to Phoenix Sky Harbor Airport on my motorcycle and couldn’t help but think how much time I would have saved if only lane-splitting were legal here in Arizona.  I have had the pleasure of lane-splitting in California and what a great option it is for motorcyclists to have in their traffic management arsenal.  Not only does it save time for the rider, but it also reduces the length of the traffic jam by filling in some otherwise unused holes.

California is the benchmark for lane-splitting.  From the California Highway Patrol FAQ section of their website:

Can motorcycle riders “split” lanes and ride between other vehicles?

Answer: Lane splitting by motorcycles is permissible but must be done in a safe and prudent manner.

Personally, I am not all that thrilled with the verbiage “safe and prudent manner” because it is subjective.  I think a better method is some sort of objective measurement (10mph over traffic speed), but that may be rather difficult to execute accurately.  I think its still a thought starter.

So I ask of the Arizona, and all folks really, if there is interest in a lobbying effort to get lane-splitting under consideration or at least studied?  The only way this can happen is with numbers.  Please vote in the poll below.  I have specifically eliminated nuance in the poll question itself (CNN/Gallup take note).  Please use the comment section for the discussion about trade-offs (trade lane-splitting for mandatory helmet law…for example), “yes but”, etc.  Please also leave your initials and city & state of residency.

Would you like lane-splitting to be legal in Arizona (or your state)?
View Results

I ask very little of the MBG reading community…so with little guilt, please forward this to other forums, bulletin boards, riding buddies, etc., especially in Arizona.  I am curious as to how many Arizonans have given this some thought.  How many would be willing to write a letter to our local reps?  And overall, is this a good idea (Californians please give your opinions as to the merits and/or faults)?

25 Comments

Driving a car in California stop and go traffic and having a motorcycle come past me has scared me many times. Driving only a few miles per hour you expect everyone else to be driving at the same speed and will move right or left to see what is slowing traffic. Having a motorcycle come up behind you at a much greater speed is very unexpected. And with the majority of riders lacking in basic rider skills this is a recipe for disaster. Of course loud pipes save lives.

Comment by cyclebrain | May 3rd, 2007 10:14 pm | Permalink

The actual verbiage of the California law is not “lane splitting” but “lane sharing.” It is legal for two vehicles to share the lane. In common use, a motorcycle may “split lanes” and it is legal to do so unless that motorcycle rider is being unsafe. Of course this is subjective… and if there is an accident the car is “usually to blame.” The officer who takes the report has the option to assign guilt to whomever he sees as being unsafe… so if the rider was going 60MPH in between stopped cars… that rider will be at fault.

Anyway, I live in San Francisco and I am very much in support of our lane sharing law. I would probably support it in most places I might live, but I do think that there are some places it’s not safe.

Mainly, I think it’s a good idea in places where there are year-round riders. I used to live in Chicago, and the 3-4 month riding season just did not give the car drivers enough time to get used to the bikes being around. Here in the Bay Area, all drivers are used to seeing motorcycles all the time, so it’s part of their driving strategy. I still get cut off sometimes, but nothing like it was in Chicago.

Another reason is that places where the weather is bad, the roads get really bad. If you are splitting lanes and you hit a pothole, you can be thrown into the side of a car. Chicago had no way of fixing the potholes quickly enough once the weather turned.

Some cars still get upset when I ride past, I guess they feel like I’m cutting in line or something like that. It just doesn’t make any sense to me. I agree with the above poster about the bike scaring the driver — I try pretty hard to not rev my motor or do anything too startling. I think this is one thing that really pushes the buttons of many drivers, giving us riders a bad name. of course, you can’t please all the people all the time, and there have been plenty of times a car driver has startled me with their bonehead move. So I guess it evens out…

Just a few thoughts -

Bruce

Comment by Drift | May 3rd, 2007 10:27 pm | Permalink

Should be legalized as its a safe way to travel in heavy traffic. Did it nearly every day living 15+ yrs in Calif. Still do it time to time here in Phx.

Comment by Chuck B | May 3rd, 2007 10:50 pm | Permalink

[...] has a new editorial on whether or not lane splitting should be legal. I don’t really think it should be encouraged by traffic authorities, but I don’t think [...]

We’re one of the only countries in the world that haven’t embraced this energy and time saving philosophy in some form.

The only “real” reason people are against it, is the childish “no cutsies” excuse.

California statistics prove the risk no greater than normal (in-lane) riding …. but the general public doesn’t like it because it “scares” them. Also, see “no cutsies” above.

We take many risks while riding, but where’s the reward? The only one I know of is HOV lane privilege.

The AMA needs to lay off the over zealous persecution of helmet laws and start investing some of it’s resources in something that will truly benefit riders ….. Lane Splitting.

All we need is a federal law and education.

Rhino

Comment by Anonymous | May 4th, 2007 8:55 am | Permalink

I recall many years ago that one reason California was able to get lane sharing approved was because motorcycles needed cooling (sounds far-fetched even as I type it). Of course now that excuse wouldn’t apply since so many bikes are water cooled except for Harley’s and older bikes.

Here in Los Angeles I’ve split lanes for years. However I try to keep it to the edge of the carpool lanes since it gives me a little more space. Riding a large cruiser with beachbars makes “lane sharing” a challenge and my grips become mirror whackers. I see the “no-cutsie” BS on a daily basis, where a driver will edge to the right when they see a rider approaching from behind.

Not sure a federal law for lane sharing would ever fly, since the fed has deregulated things like speed limits etc to the states. Its certainly something that AMA should concentrate on at the state level, along with tougher laws against those who would point their vehicle at a cyclists as a weapon.

Comment by Kenfuzed | May 4th, 2007 9:42 am | Permalink

Lane splitting in California is legal. The reason lane splitting is legal in California is; (a) It is safer for an unprotected biker to be able to split lanes in bumper to bumper traffic rather than being exposed to traffic which is a danger to bikers in those conditions; and (b) due to the fact that many motorcycles are air cooled, keeping motorcycles sitting in bumper to bumper traffic poses a safety risk to the motorcycle rider and other traffic by way of the motorcycle overheating and potentially catching on fire.

I was just staying in Kingman for the Laughlin River Run. I did not encounter any situations where I needed to lane split except on Casino Row in Laughlin. However I support lane splitting and sharing laws for all States.

Norman Gregory Fernandez, Esq.
http://www.bikerlawblog.com

Comment by Norman Gregory Fernandez, Esq. | May 5th, 2007 12:04 am | Permalink

While enjoying the late night comedy of Craig Ferguson the other night (The, Late, Late Show - after Letterman), during his monologue Craig revealed his enjoyment of two-wheeled travel. He was bemoaning car drivers who are “offended” by motorcycles splitting lanes and made the following quote:

“I risk my life on a motorcycle so I don’t have to wait in line”

Priceless!

Rhino

Comment by Anonymous | May 8th, 2007 11:06 am | Permalink

[...] at motorcyclebloggers.com posed this question to his readers, and asked others to do the [...]

It’s illegal in my country too, but it doesn’t stop us :)

Comment by foo | May 9th, 2007 11:09 am | Permalink

I think this is a recipe for disaster. Traffic in Phoenix is made up of stressed-out, underpaid (Arizona is a “right to work” state.) crazy motorists that do NOT see other vehicles as having human beings in them. All the average Phoenix cager wants to do is get home, RIGHT NOW.. after a stressful day.

Now, add some young squids that will take such a thing to then scream between cars at 80+ mph. toss in the inevitible accidents..

And watch our insurance rates soar.

Not to mention that the local gov’t here has hinted that enacting a lane-splitting law will come with a helmet law included. I wear mine but believe in freedom of choice.
Chip

Comment by C,Johnson | May 13th, 2007 1:48 pm | Permalink

I think Lane splitting in Arizona is a good idea …..It sucks to be stuck in stop and go traffic on a air cooled bike with temps hovering in the 100’s….Both my bike and I need a little breeze to stay alive…..plus having to breath that crap that comes out of those unclean burning diesel trucks is murder….

Comment by turbokawi | May 13th, 2007 3:18 pm | Permalink

I’d support lane splitting. I would prefer it not tied to any pork legislation. I am a ATGATT kind of guy, but would veto a lane splitting law if tied to a helmet ruling. Keep separate issues separate! I think about the only time I’d be using a lane split is in rush hour when all the cars are already stopped for a light and I would be stuck for two or 3 red light cycles. I am in gear on an air cooled bike, just for the record. I am not too trusting of the average Phx area driver, my life depends on it!

Erich

Comment by Erich | May 13th, 2007 9:04 pm | Permalink

I learned to ride here in california and for me its great but here are the rules i go by: 1st i only do it when traffic is traveling less than 25mph and then i only travel 10-15 over that. following these rules should give drivers that constantly scan there mirrors the chance to see you comming between them. now some riders just act stupid just like some drivers act stupid. if you ask me neither should be on the road but since they are when i’m driving i keep an eye out and when i’m riding i constantly scan drivers will give tell tale signs that they are going to do something oh and keep your brake covered during your lane splitting.

Comment by chickenheart | June 21st, 2007 5:59 pm | Permalink

Been riding for years both in states and Europe courtesy of US Army.
Lane splitting at a crawl while cars are stopped or moving very slowly is the safe way to go. AND it should be legalized! As other have noted, riding in Phoenix AKA Hell is painful while the car lemmings have A/C on freeze and trucks and cars pollute more that a bike.
Trying to keep rant down as I just got a ticket on a 112 degree day. So am now looking to see whats available w/Abate and the “elected” representatives on how to effect change.

Thanks,
Rey

Comment by Rey | July 21st, 2007 11:35 am | Permalink

[...] has a new editorial on whether or not lane splitting should be legal. I don’t really think it should be encouraged by traffic authorities, but I don’t think [...]

I myself have been riding since I was an early teen. Even with the extensive years that I have been in the saddle, I would not feel comfortable splitting traffic and I don’t think it should be legal anywhere, ever. I hear all of the excuses like my bike gets hot, I get hot, I don’t want to wait in traffic, and my favorite, my bike might overheat and catch on fire. We chose to ride… That does not give us any special rights or privleges. When you chose to ride in Socal or Phoenix or where ever, you knew what the weather was. Don’t sit there and say you shouldn’t have to breath exhaust fumes. Those guys in the cars are the majority by a huge margin. Stop whining and get over it……You made the choice, everyone else should not have to adapt to your needs.

Comment by TMAC | October 3rd, 2007 4:39 pm | Permalink

[...] has a new editorial on whether or not lane splitting should be legal. I don’t really think it should be encouraged by traffic authorities, but I don’t think [...]

Comment by Motorcycle Headlines and Links May 4, 2007 : Bikers @ Howrah | October 23rd, 2007 11:02 am | Permalink

Frankly, I think “lane splitting” NEEDS to be adopted along with a helmet law. I have been riding in California for 15yrs and I do Lane Share only when traffic is stopped or lower than 20mph. I will only go over traffic by 5-10mph and always with both brakes covered. I have been in a few accidents where someone who didnt see me pulled in front of me to change lanes without warning… and the only reason that I am here to tell you about it today is because I was wearing a full face helmet and riding gear. Don’t kid yourselves, “lane sharing” isn’t a right of motorcycles, it’s a privilege granted by a handful of states, but protecting yourselves with the right gear (helmet mostly) and education for undertaking this dangerous driving strategy IS your right and responsibility. Happy, and Safe riding to you all.

Comment by BaldGuySV1000 | November 24th, 2007 7:00 pm | Permalink

I lived in the bay area for fourteen years and rode for about ten. After I got a car I moved…
I’m now in Arizona and I would get a bike if I could split lanes, boy that would be great. Oh and not wearing a helmet because it looks cool but you don’t split? Posers…

Comment by JJ | February 18th, 2008 10:17 pm | Permalink

Why is it that a bicycle can pass me in traffic and go to the front of the line at a stop light, but I can’t on a motorcycle?

Comment by Dan D | March 27th, 2008 6:07 pm | Permalink

I’ve spent the majority of my riding life in CA and having to now drive through Phoenix without lane splitting is unbearable. It’s excruciating to have be stuck in first gear for 10 miles on the I-10. And this is coming from a guy who, before I started riding, was driving my car and exited the HOV lane on the 405 in what I thought was a safe manner, but a cyclist coming up fast through the lanes hit me square in the middle of my bumper. He even told me he was almost able to stop in time. I was irritated that my insurance caved immediately, saying I had made an improper lane change, but after being on the other side now, I get it. But that will be the challenge; getting car drivers up to speed on the law. If anyone has ideas of how to get this going, I’m in.

Comment by taxwielder | May 16th, 2008 8:25 pm | Permalink

I would love to be able to freely and safely cut through gridlock traffic at 10-15 mph and not sit stoppped on my bike roasting my chestnuts on the tank in 115 degree PHX summer weather, or more like 130-140 sitting on the new black rubberized asphalt surfaces of the freeways we have now. Of course it will always get abused as everything does, but if a law was written correctly and not vague, it could be an excellent opportunity for motorcyclists all through the valley. If anything, it helps the environment by not having that many more vehicles sitting and idling on the freeways for hours per day… 40mpg on my 2 wheeler in AZ summer isn’t such a bonus when I have AC in my truck and have to weigh saving a few bucks in gas against being fried on the 101 griddle twice a day, sucking exhaust fumes and CO the entire time… It would probably be healthier to be a smoker in that sense…

Comment by Josh | May 23rd, 2008 7:29 pm | Permalink

i would be more than happy to have to wear a helmet as long as i can split lanes. i think riders in congested communities like phoenix would be more willing to wear protective gear if they knew they werent going to be stuck in the blazing sun as traffic creeps along. helmet laws dont bother me as i wear a full face helmet anyway. how embaressing it must be to die in first gear on the city streets all because you smacked your melon on the pavement. i live in california but am moving to az in two weeks and cant believe im not going to be able to split anymore. i mean like what are you supposed to do with an air cooled bike? shut down and push the thing along? oh and to the idiot that thinks most bikes now are water cooled you should go to a dealership and see that MANY bikes are still made air cooled, not just harleys.

Comment by tim f | June 29th, 2008 3:47 pm | Permalink

This is something that really needs to be put into place. I to am from California and I have always yielded to motorcycles splitting lanes, even before I started riding. I mean, who cares, it’s not like I was going anywhere anyway. I ride an air-cooled bike (katana) and there is no way I can sit in traffic for an hour in the middle of summer. Everyone should be wearing a helmet anyway, so if it comes attached with a helmet requirement, even better. Yes, there is an added risk, but if it can work in California…it can work here.

Comment by randy | July 3rd, 2008 12:00 pm | Permalink

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Live Comment Preview

Comment by Somebody

Powered by WordPress 2.7.1    Rendered in 15 queries and 0.403 seconds.    CleanBreeze Theme   
   

Bad Behavior has blocked 913 access attempts in the last 7 days.